Contingent vs retained recruitment comes down to when you pay and what that payment buys. Contingent means you pay only if you hire a candidate the agency introduced, and it suits roles where plenty of good people are already looking. Retained means you pay in stages for an exclusive, researched search, and it suits senior, scarce or confidential travel tech hires.
A third option, exclusive recruitment search on a contingent fee, sits between the two. This guide defines all three, compares them side by side and gives a decision guide for typical travel and hospitality tech hires in the UK and US. Fees are commonly a percentage of first-year salary, but every agency sets its own terms, so read them before you sign.
Contingent vs retained recruitment: the models defined
Retained search: An engagement in which one firm is paid in instalments, starting before any candidate is presented, to run a defined search for a single role. You pay for the work and the process, not only the outcome.
Contingent recruitment is the default for most permanent hiring. You pay nothing unless you hire someone the agency introduced, and several agencies may work the same vacancy at once. Contingent fees are commonly a percentage of first-year salary, usually base salary. In the US you will see it written as "contingent" or "contingency"; in the UK "contingency" is more usual. They mean the same thing.
Retained search is what most people mean by executive search. Fees are commonly a percentage of first-year compensation. The classic structure is three equal instalments: at kick-off, at shortlist and at placement. The fee base is often total cash compensation, so it can include a guaranteed or target bonus.
Exclusive recruitment search on a contingent basis means you still pay only on a hire. The difference is that no other agency works the role for a set period. Think of it as a trade: you give the agency a clear run, and it spends more time on your role than it would on an open brief.
UK and US wording. UK agencies talk about a rebate if a hire leaves early; US firms usually say replacement guarantee. UK salaries are normally quoted as base, while US search fees are often calculated on total cash compensation. Always check which base your fee uses.
What exclusive recruitment search does and does not give you
Exclusivity removes the race. When several agencies compete on a first-to-submit basis, speed tends to beat fit. With one agency, the recruiter can spend time on outreach, calibration and candidate care instead of racing to send a CV.
It does not remove risk on your side. You rely on one firm's network and one recruiter's attention. Guidance for founders suggests exclusive windows of around 30 days are common, although some agencies ask for 60 or 90. The same guidance suggests protections worth asking for: a clear definition of what breaks exclusivity, such as inbound applications, and a milestone review. For example, if the agency has not delivered a set number of vetted candidates by day 45, exclusivity converts to non-exclusive.
Retained mandates run longer. The same guidance notes that retained firms on CTO-level searches typically want exclusivity of 90 to 120 days, because they commit researcher time up front.
How the three models compare
Contingent, exclusive contingent and retained recruitment compared.
| Factor | Contingent | Exclusive (contingent fee) | Retained |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost structure | Commonly a percentage of first-year salary, paid only on hire | Pay-on-hire fee, percentage agreed in writing | Commonly a percentage of first-year compensation, in three instalments |
| Commitment | None either side; several agencies may work the role | One agency for a set window; you close the role to others | Written mandate; you pay before a shortlist exists |
| Speed | Fast to first CVs, mostly from active candidates | Usually quick to a first slate, with one point of contact | Slower to start; senior searches often run 90–120 days |
| Depth | Mainly people already looking | More focused than open contingent, but not funded for deep research | Market mapping, direct approach to passive candidates, structured assessment |
| Best for | Mid-level roles with a visible pool | Hard-to-fill mid to senior roles where you want focus without a retainer | C-suite and VP roles, confidential or scarce hires |
Two cautions. A retained fee on total cash compensation will be higher than one calculated on base salary if the role carries a large bonus. And a lower headline percentage is not automatically cheaper. A contingent search that runs for months with no hire costs you nothing in fees, but it costs you in management time and pipeline.
Executive search for travel tech: when retained earns its fee
Executive search in travel tech is a small-world exercise. Candidates for a CRO, CPO or CTO role at a PMS, revenue management or distribution vendor are usually employed, usually happy enough and often known to each other. They do not apply to adverts and they rarely register with agencies. That is the case for paying for research and direct approach, which is the core of executive search.
Retained also helps when confidentiality matters. If you are replacing a sitting CTO or restructuring a sales leadership team, you may not want the role circulating among several agencies. One firm under a written mandate limits who knows.
It is not a guarantee. You pay the early instalments whether or not the search ends in a hire, and the quality depends on the firm's real network in your niche. Ask who will run the search day to day and whether they have placed into your segment before. A global generalist brand can be a weaker fit than a specialist boutique for an NDC or hotel-software role.
A decision guide for travel and hospitality tech hiring
Match the model to the scenario, not to habit. These are judgement calls, not rules.
- Mid-level commercial or customer-facing hires with a visible pool (account executives, CSMs, onboarding specialists): contingent is usually sensible. See sales and commercial and customer success and onboarding hiring. Limit yourself to one or two agencies so candidates are not approached repeatedly.
- A first senior commercial leader in a new market, such as a Head of Sales for a PMS vendor entering the US: consider exclusive or retained. The pool is small, the hire sets the pipeline and a miss is costly. Our first-leader playbook covers the role itself.
- Niche technical specialists in areas like GDS and NDC airline technology or PMS integration: try exclusive contingent with a milestone review. Move to retained if the role is senior or the first slate misses.
- CTO, CPO, CRO or other C-suite hires: retained is the conventional choice, and there is a good reason for it. These people are passive, the decision is board-level and the search needs structured assessment and references.
- A confidential replacement: retained, with a named contact and a clear rule on who is told.
- Several similar hires in a growth phase, such as five CSMs across two regions: contingent with a preferred supplier, or embedded recruitment if the volume justifies it.
- A role that has sat open on contingent for weeks: the pool may not be visible after all. Switch to exclusive or retained, and review the brief and the pay band first.
- Cross-border hires, such as a UK company hiring a US VP: retained or exclusive tends to work better, because the agency needs to understand both UK and US pay and notice norms.
Five checks before you sign any agreement
Work through these before choosing a model.
- Put a cost on a miss. For a leadership hire, estimate the months of lost pipeline, product delay or team churn. If the figure dwarfs the fee, retained is easier to justify.
- Test whether the pool is visible. If many people already do this job and are actively looking, contingent will work. If you cannot name ten likely candidates, it will not.
- Agree the fee base in writing. Confirm whether it is base salary or total cash, how bonus and equity are treated and which currency applies.
- Set milestones and exits. Agree a date for the first slate and the number of candidates. Agree what happens if they are missed, such as exclusivity converting to non-exclusive.
- Check the guarantee. Ask what happens if the hire leaves early, how long the cover lasts and whether it is a replacement search or a refund.
Where each model falls short
Being fair to all three matters, because each fails in its own way.
Contingent can create noise. Several agencies sending overlapping CVs means your team reviews a lot of unfiltered candidates, and the best passive people may never see the role. Exclusive depends on one firm. If that firm underdelivers, you lose weeks unless you wrote in an exit. Retained asks for trust and money up front, and a weak search still invoices on schedule. It also needs a decisive internal process, since a slow client can undo even a well-run search.
Mixing models is normal. Many employers use contingent for volume roles and retained for the two or three hires a year that shape the company. If you want to talk through how that would look for your hiring plan, the for clients page explains how we work with employers, and our process page sets out the steps.
Tell us the role, the market and how urgent it is, and we will say which model we would use and why. Submit a brief
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between contingent and retained recruitment?
With contingent recruitment you pay only if you hire a candidate the agency introduced, and several agencies may work the role. With retained recruitment you pay in stages, starting before a shortlist, to engage one firm exclusively. Contingent rewards speed and suits visible talent pools. Retained pays for research, assessment and commitment on senior or scarce roles.
How much does retained search cost compared with contingent?
Both are commonly a percentage of first-year salary, with retained fees usually the higher of the two. Retained is usually billed in three instalments. The fee base can differ, with retained often calculated on total cash compensation, so confirm it in writing.
What is an exclusive recruitment search?
An exclusive recruitment search means one agency has sole rights to fill a role for a set period, often around 30 days for contingent fee arrangements. You still pay only on a hire, unless the deal is retained. It gives the recruiter a clear run, but you depend on one firm, so agree milestones and an exit.
When should a travel tech company use retained executive search?
Use retained search for C-suite and VP hires, confidential replacements and scarce specialists, such as a CTO or CRO at a PMS, distribution or payments vendor. These candidates are usually employed and do not apply to adverts. Retained funds the research and direct approach needed to reach them, though it does not guarantee a hire.
Can I use contingent and retained recruitment together?
Yes, and many employers do. A common pattern is contingent recruitment for volume or mid-level roles, such as customer success managers and account executives, and retained or exclusive search for the few leadership hires each year. Keep the agreements separate and make clear which roles sit under which terms.
Is exclusive recruitment the same as retained search?
No. Retained search is exclusive but also paid in stages regardless of outcome. Exclusive contingent search gives one agency sole rights for a period, but you pay only if you hire. The first commits both sides financially. The second commits only your access to other agencies.
Sources
- Contingency vs Retained Search: Fees and Terms Explained
- Retained vs Contingent Search: How to Choose in 2026 - Pin
- Recruitment Fee Agreements: 5 Clauses Founders Should Negotiate - Dover
- Contingency vs Retained Search: Which Recruiting Fee Wins?
- Contingency recruiting agreement template: short-form terms, exclusive and multi-agency versions



